THE FOOD LISTNew York · eats · markets · carts

everything Eats 158 Markets 22 Carts 17 $ $$ $$$
all of new york Downtown 14 Hell's Kitchen 18 Little Italy 17 Midtown 21 Uptown 16 East Side 18 Harlem 17 The Bronx 19 Brooklyn 21 Queens 21 Staten Island 15

2 showing · 197 on the list

Basilio Inn

$$$ eat italian Staten Island

Staten Island's oldest restaurant (1921), hidden in a converted 1850s carriage house near South Beach — homemade pasta, produce from their own garden, and one surviving bocce court out back.

Order: Spiedini alla romana to start, then whatever pasta features the garden's produce; ask about the squash blossoms in summer.

verified open Aug 2026 (basilioinn.com + OpenTable active, Yelp updated May 2026); tucked on a dead-end street — easy to drive past

6 Galesville Ct (off Lily Pond Ave, near South Beach), Staten Island, NY 10305 · map

added 2026-08-07 · verified 2026-08-07

Enoteca Maria

$$$ eat italian Staten Island

The famous nonnas restaurant: real grandmothers — Italian nightly, plus a rotating nonna from a different country — cooking in a tiny St. George room blocks from the ferry. Menu changes with whoever's at the stove.

Order: Whatever the guest nonna is making that night — check the board and trust her; the handmade pastas from the Italian kitchen are the constant.

verified open Aug 2026 (Yelp updated Aug 2026, OpenTable active, Michelin Guide listed); Thu-Sun only, from 3:30pm — reserve, the room is tiny

27 Hyatt St (off Central Ave, St. George), Staten Island, NY 10301 · map

added 2026-08-07 · verified 2026-08-07

197 spots · list last verified 2026-08-07 · every entry was checked as operating when added, then reviewed by a skeptical editor — but this is New York: places close, carts move, hours lie. Look before you trek.